There is possibly nothing better on a clear, sunny, fall day than a trip to the apple orchard. The air is crisp and clean, slightly tinged with that edge of coolness that September brings, the grass is still slightly wet with last night’s dew in the shady spots under the trees, and S-man is illegally dangling from the branches, trying to reach that one beautiful red Jonamac that is just out of reach, while my ever-paranoid-about-authority-figures self cringes and looks around hoping that nobody sees him and kicks us out of the orchard.
Heading out to Roger’s Orchards in Southington, is one of our favorite fall traditions, and one that invariably leads to the heavenly scent of cinnamon and apple wafting through the house from the kitchen. When we went for our yearly romp through the orchard recently, and returned with our two and a half bajillion pounds of Macs and Jonamacs (those were the only two available for picking at the time – I personally favor the tart Macouns), I got all nostalgic and decided to whip out some apple pie with homemade crust. Granted, this is mostly because I didn’t have the store bought crusts in the fridge, like I usually do, and I did happen to have a crapload of butter, but still…
So I thought to myself, “Of course I can make pie crust. I made pie crust when I was a kid. My pie crust won a blue ribbon in a 4-H contest one time.” I’m also pretty sure that they gave out blue ribbons for just about anything. Wow, you painted a cat face on a pumpkin? Blue ribbon! Ooooh, those brownies were actually edible! Blue ribbon! I’m not actually trying to belittle my pie. It was really good, I’m sure. And the crusts were basically the Betty Crocker recipe minus the Crisco and plus more butter, so why not just tweak the Joy of Cooking Deluxe Butter Crust recipe by, again, ignoring the Crisco and replacing it with my favorite fatty substance?
And so I did. I cut the butter into the flour with the “dual butter knife technique.” I felt very Shaolin Temple. Very secret technique. May cause instant death to your unwitting enemy. Don’t mess with them! Yes, two of them. At once!
Unfortunately, I started mixing the water into the dough with my hot little hands, which of course got the butter all melty, plus I was working right next to the preheating oven, so when I started trying to roll out my dough it just turned into a gooey buttery disaster stuck to my rolling pin. Ew. So I somehow managed to ball it up again and stick it in the freezer, then roll it out, and transfer the flaking, cracking, gaping-hole-in-the-crust pieces to my pie plate. The bottom crust I pieced back together, thinking, no one will see the big hot mess of that crust because it will be under the apples. No big deal. The top crust went much smoother, but of course I put it on top of the apples crooked, and then had to try to move a crust that was disintegrating every time I touched it. There was no secret Shaolin Temple technique to help me with this one. Finally, I was able to manuever it close enough to lined up, and just folded the edges under and squished them with a fork and then stabbed the crust with a knife. And even though my Macs turned into a tasty soggy mush in my pie and flattened out ridiculously, and my crust was almost a complete miss, the pie was absolutely delicious, and if I hadn’t told you, you probably wouldn’t have known about all of the antics involved in trying to get that darn pie crust on the stupid pie. I’m really not sure how my middle school 4-H going self did it.
In the days after making the pie, I still had approximately 3 tons of apples left, so I pulled out some apple “bread” mix (also from Roger’s Orchards) that my sister-in-law had given to me about a year ago and again, decided to replace the vegetable oil with butter. I know, I know, I know. But really, I ran out of canola oil and I HAD to. This was mostly a bad idea because it turned the “bread” into more of a “cake.” I think they just call it bread because it sounds healthier and because you bake it in the shape of a bread loaf. But believe you me, there is nothing bready about this bread. It is sweet like heck, and crumbly, fatty and delicious.
The other reason, though, that replacing the oil with butter was a bad idea, was because then I ate about half of it in one sitting. With butter on top. Yikes. Maybe I should go get MYcholesterol checked. It did have apples and walnuts in it, though, so I get some health points for that, right?